Top 6 Disadvantages of Contracting

Working as an independent contractor has emerged as a prevalent alternative to traditional full-time roles- in large part because being a contract worker usually means having more flexibility and accessing a higher pay.

However, before you dive into the world of contracting, it's important to consider the differences between permanent and contract employees, and the disadvantages of contract employment in the UK.

Being a permanent employee and contracting are two distinct types of work arrangements. As such, there are several differences in terms of employment status, contractual obligations, and long-term commitment.

Employees

In permanent employment, individuals are hired by a company as full-time employees and enter into an employment contract. They typically work for a single employer on an ongoing basis, with a more stable and long-term commitment.

Permanent employees can receive benefits such as paid vacation, sick leave, health insurance, retirement plans, and other employment perks. They also have a consistent salary or wage, often receive training and career development opportunities, and are subject to the company's policies and regulations.

Contract Work

Contracting (as a freelancer or a self-employed person) involves working on a project or assignment basis for a specific period.

Contract workers are not employees of the hiring company but rather work as independent entities or through an intermediary such as an umbrella company. They sign contracts or agreements for specific projects or timeframes, and their work is often result-oriented or based on deliverables. In some cases (though not all), a contractor can work on multiple contracts at the same time - thus potentially making more money.

Contractors are responsible for their own taxes, insurance, and other business expenses. They have more flexibility in choosing projects, setting their rates, and managing their working hours. However, contractors typically do not receive employee benefits, sick pay, or annual leave, and are not entitled to the same level of job security as permanent employees.

In many cases, self employed people who want to remain their own boss go on to starting a limited company.

When comparing contract workers to employees, several distinctions become apparent:

1. Job Structure: Employees typically have permanent positions within a company, enjoying stable roles and responsibilities. In contrast, contract workers are engaged for specific projects or time frames, with their employment contingent upon the duration of the contract.
2. Benefits and Protections: Employees often receive comprehensive benefits, including health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off. They also benefit from statutory protections such as redundancy pay and maternity leave. In contrast, contract workers usually do not have access to such benefits and protections, leaving them financially vulnerable and without safety nets.
3. Job Security: Employees generally have greater job security compared to contract workers. While employees may face layoffs or job losses in adverse circumstances, they often have legal recourse and may be entitled to severance packages. Contract workers, on the other hand, are subject to the uncertainties of contract renewals and project availability, making their employment tenure less predictable.
4. Income Stability: Employees typically receive a steady salary or wage, providing them with consistent income to meet their financial obligations. In contrast, contract workers' income may fluctuate depending on the duration and nature of their contracts. This variability can pose challenges in budgeting and financial planning, leading to periods of financial strain during gaps between contracts.
5. Workplace Integration: Employees are typically fully integrated into the organizational structure and culture, fostering a sense of belonging and trust within the workplace. Contract workers, however, may feel like outsiders, as they are often hired for specific tasks or projects and may not have the opportunity to develop long-term relationships with colleagues.

‍

‍

1. Lack of Job Security: Contract workers often face uncertain futures, as their employment hinges on project completion or contract renewal. Due to the flexible nature of their working relationships, contractors aren’t guaranteed work after the end of assignment or project. This instability can lead to anxiety and financial stress, with the constant need to secure the next gig looming overhead.
2. Inconsistent Income: Contractors often experience fluctuating income levels, depending on the availability of projects and the success of their businesses. There might be periods of high earnings, followed by breaks with little to no income.
3. Limited Employment Benefits: Compared to permanent employees, contractors typically don't receive benefits such as paid leave, healthcare coverage, retirement plans, or other perks commonly provided by employers.
4. Responsible for Taxes and Finances: Contract workers are responsible for managing their own taxes, including filing tax returns and paying taxes owed. This means keeping track of income, deductions, and any applicable self-employment taxes. Failure to comply with tax requirements can result in penalties and legal issues.
5. Isolation and Limited Professional Development: Contractors often work independently and may miss out on the collaborative environment and opportunities for skill development available to permanent employees within a company. They may also feel isolated within the workplace, as they are not fully integrated into the organizational culture and may miss out on opportunities for networking and career advancement.
6. Difficulty in Obtaining Loans or Mortgages: Contract workers may struggle to demonstrate consistent income to lenders, making it difficult to qualify for loans or mortgages. Lenders often prefer applicants with stable, predictable income streams, which contract workers may not always have.

So, it's vital to understand these drawbacks, you you can make more informed decisions when considering contracting as a career path.

‍

Permanent employment provides stability, benefits, and long-term commitment, while being a contract worker can offer flexibility, autonomy, and a project-based work structure.

Many contractors feel that autonomy and flexibility (two of the main contracting advantages) are more important than the downsides, as you get greater control as a self-employed person than being an employee. However, it's important to keep in mind that contracting also involved many potential disadvantages, including job insecurity, lack of benefits, and limited employment rights.

Ultimately, the decision depends on individual preferences, financial goals, and lifestyle considerations, requiring careful evaluation and possibly seeking advice from professionals like contractor accountants or career advisors.